I recently reviewed a paper for a journal and my recommendation was “accept with minor modifications”, whereby my suggestions for improvement were provided to the authors – as is usual. Eventually, the paper was resubmitted – my suggestions were implemented and I recommended “accept.” But I noticed that the other reviewer had recommended reject with no comments to the authors other than saying it was an article of limited interest. As a sometimes author I would have been pretty unhappy with such sparse feedback. I think authors deserve better.
Reviewing an article without commenting